
CompareRentCaddie vs a spreadsheet for rent by the room
A spreadsheet is free, it is yours, and it does exactly what you type. The trouble in a rooming house is how much there is to type: six rents, six deposits, one bill split six ways, and a text to whoever has not paid.
The short answer
With one house and residents who pay on time, a spreadsheet is fine. Keep it.
Once you are chasing payments, splitting bills by hand and rebuilding the numbers at tax time, the spreadsheet is costing you evenings. RentCaddie does that work for $27 a month paid yearly up to 5 active leases, or $197 a month paid yearly for 6 to 25.
Side by side
The work a spreadsheet leaves with you
One BiggerPockets member explained why they stopped splitting utilities at all: "it's a lot easier than venmoing everyone $37.13 here, $7.59 there, $14.28 over there." Including utilities in rent is one answer. Having the split done for you is another.
A spreadsheet records what happened. It does not ask anyone for money, remind anyone, or notice a deposit deadline. In a house with several leases, that is where the hours go.
Moving off the spreadsheet
Bring your sheet in with the Smart Importer, which maps your columns to properties, rooms, residents and leases, and shows a preview before anything is saved. Or email hello@rentcaddie.com and we help you set up your houses.
When the spreadsheet is the better pick
- You have one house and every resident pays on time without a reminder.
- Utilities are included in rent, so there is nothing to split.
- You would rather spend the time than the money.
Common questions
Is a spreadsheet enough to run a rooming house?
Can I import my spreadsheet into RentCaddie?
Will my residents have to pay extra to pay online?
What happens to my data if I leave?
Go deeper
Sources
Prices and features change. Each link below was read on the date shown; check it before you decide.
- [1] BiggerPockets forum: Rent by the room strategy, utilities as of 09/30/2026